Senate Filibuster Showdown: Will Democrats Finally Pull the Trigger?

With Democrats set to run the Senate in January, the 60-vote rule that has restrained every majority for generations is suddenly on the table, and nobody in either party can say who it will protect next. The midterms are over. The filibuster fight has only begun. Democrats won control of both chambers on November 3, according to Associated Press projections, and the new majority takes power January 3, 2027 [AP projection, per press reports]. Within days, Sen. Chris Van Hollen announced a challenge to Chuck Schumer’s leadership while saying he wants the filibuster abolished [press reports]. A rule that has shaped American lawmaking for generations is now a live question.
Is the “Seven-Step Plan” Real, or Already Out of Date?
A viral post claims the Democratic Socialists of America have a seven-step plan to take over the government, and that it all “ends on Tuesday if they lose.” That Tuesday has come and gone. Democrats did not lose, so the post’s own test has been settled. We could not locate a published DSA document containing those seven steps. What is documented is narrower and still significant: the group’s new program calls for abolishing the Senate, the presidency and the Supreme Court, according to columnist Rich Lowry [opinion, National Review]. DSA co-chair Gustavo Gordillo called the Senate “undemocratic” on Fox News, and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has said she opposes the filibuster [Fox News; opinion, National Review]. Fairness requires a distinction. DSA’s platform is not the Democratic Party’s platform, and as far as public reporting shows, party leaders have not adopted abolishing the Senate as a goal. The filibuster, however, is a different matter.
What Has Actually Changed Since Election Day?
Democrats are projected to hold at least 54 Senate seats, with the Alaska race uncalled as of November 13 and a ranked-choice tabulation scheduled for November 18 [press reports]. That is a commanding majority, but it is short of the 60 votes needed to end debate on most bills [Senate Rule XXII]. Without those votes, calls to dump the filibuster entirely are growing inside the party [press reports]. Texas Senator-elect James Talarico has called the rule a “Jim Crow relic” and wants it gone [Daily Wire]. Schumer has declined to say whether Democrats will eliminate it, and Sen. Andy Kim has warned the move could be a “double-edged sword” [press reports]. 60 votes. That is what stands between a Senate majority and its agenda. The question no one in the incoming majority has answered: will they keep it?
Support Independent Local Journalism
TheTownHall.News is a non-profit reader-supported journalism. Just $5 helps us hire local reporters, investigate important issues, and hold public officials accountable across Alameda County. If you believe our community deserves strong, independent journalism, please consider donating $5 today to support our work.How Would Democrats Even Pull It Off?
Not by the book. Changing Senate rules formally takes a two-thirds vote, which Democrats will not have, so the route is the so-called nuclear option: a senator raises a point of order and a simple majority overrules the precedent [labor policy analysis, OnLabor]. No Republican votes required. Democrats have tried to get close before. In January 2022, a push to change the rules failed when Sens. Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema joined every Republican in opposition, leaving Democrats short of the 50 votes they needed [Senate roll call, Jan. 19, 2022]. Neither senator serves today, and several Democratic Senate hopefuls this cycle were more eager to repeal the rule than the members they sought to replace [Washington Examiner, June 2026]. The 60-vote rule is not in the Constitution. It is a habit of restraint, and habits only last as long as someone chooses to keep them.
Didn’t Republicans Want It Gone First?
They did, at least at the top. President Trump repeatedly urged Senate Republicans to abolish the filibuster, warning in April that Democrats would do it themselves if they won the majority [Political Wire, April 30, 2026]. Senate Republican leaders refused, and Sen. Ron Johnson warned that Democrats would act as soon as they could [Daily Wire]. That history cuts in an uncomfortable direction. The GOP’s own reluctance preserved the tool its opponents may now use, and it shows the filibuster has defenders in both parties, usually whichever one is in the minority. If the filibuster is a safeguard when your party is losing and an obstacle when it is winning, was it ever a principle at all? Limited-government conservatives have a particular stake here. The filibuster is one of the few brakes on how fast Washington can expand spending, regulation and federal power. It is imperfect, and Congress has worked around it through budget reconciliation for major tax and spending bills [Congressional Research Service, via ABC6 reporting], but removing it would remove one more check on federal growth.
What Else Falls If the 60-Vote Rule Does?
The filibuster is a gate, and several proposals wait behind it. Congress, not the Constitution, sets the size of the Supreme Court, which has ranged from six to ten seats and has been nine since 1869 [historical record, Snopes]. Expanding it would take only an ordinary law, and Bloomberg Law reported in July that Democratic candidates were amplifying calls to overhaul the Court [Bloomberg Law, via Senate GOP leader research]. Statehood for territories is another idea reportedly gaining pressure [political.org]. None of these has passed, and none is guaranteed to. Even supporters concede they would need broad support inside the party. But a Senate that can change its own rules with 50 votes can move every one of them forward without a single vote from the other side.
Is a rule worth defending only when you’re the one stuck in the minority?
What Do Supporters of Ending the Filibuster Actually Believe?
Supporters make a serious argument. Mallory McMorrow, a Democratic Senate hopeful this cycle, has said elected officials should be free to govern as they see fit and let voters judge the results [Washington Examiner, June 2026]. Talarico argues that the rule lets a minority override an elected majority. Voters just handed Democrats sweeping wins on promises to address inflation and the cost of living, and the filibuster, they say, could stop them from delivering [press reports]. There is real force in that. A party that wins an election should be held accountable for results, and a minority veto makes accountability murky. Many conservatives made the same point when Trump demanded the rule’s end. But the same logic works in reverse, and quickly. Analysts note that a narrower Democratic majority may hesitate precisely because a future Republican majority could use the same simple-majority rules against them [Justia Verdict, Nov. 11, 2026]. Voters swung hard in 2026, and could swing again in 2028. If every majority can rewrite law on a party-line vote, policy lurches with each election, and the families and businesses who have to plan around it pay the price. Majority rule and stability are both American values; the filibuster protects the second at some cost to the first.

Who Is Accountable If the Brakes Come Off?
No one voted on the filibuster this November. Voters chose senators, and those senators will now decide, by themselves, whether to alter the chamber’s most important check. That is why the position of every incoming senator matters, and why the public deserves to hear each one say it plainly before January 3. Key Questions This Story Raises:
- Will Democratic leaders commit publicly to keeping or ending the filibuster before the new Senate is sworn in?
- If the 60-vote rule falls, who decides what comes next, and what stops a future Republican majority from using the same power?
- Should a change this large to how the country is governed be settled by 50 senators, or by a broader vote? So will Democrats pull the trigger? The honest answer is that no one knows, including most of the senators who will cast the vote. The real question isn’t whether the filibuster is perfect. It’s whether anyone will defend it once it stops being convenient. Still have questions about where your senators stand? Stay informed: subscribe for daily coverage of Congress and accountability. Think others need to see this? Share the article. Want your voice to count? Find your two senators at senate.gov and ask them, in writing, whether they will vote to keep the 60-vote rule.

